DaVinci Dental
DaVinci Dental
About
Services
New Patients Insurance and Payment Reviews Blog Contact
Implants and Restoration

Wisdom Teeth: Out, or Leave Them Alone

Dr. Aleesha M. Maybury, DDS · October 4th, 2026 · 7 min read

Not every wisdom tooth needs removing. If it has come through fully, bites against something, and you can keep it clean, I will leave it and watch it. What earns removal is a gum flap that keeps getting infected, decay it is causing on the tooth in front, or a tooth you cannot reach.

Not every wisdom tooth needs removing. If it has come through fully, bites against something, and you can keep it clean, I will leave it and watch it. What earns removal is a gum flap that keeps getting infected, decay it is causing on the tooth in front, or a tooth you cannot reach.

This is the position that gets me the most disagreement from colleagues, so let me be plain about it. The idea that everybody should have all four out at eighteen as a matter of course is not how I practise. Some of those teeth are perfectly good molars that will chew food for sixty years, and taking them out is surgery with real risks attached.

So what makes one a genuine problem?

Six findings, and any one of them changes my answer.

A gum flap over a partly erupted tooth. Food and bacteria get underneath, the gum swells, and you get a week of misery that resolves and then comes back. Twice in a year and that tooth has told us what it intends to do.

Decay on the back surface of the tooth in front. This is the one that makes me angriest, because the wisdom tooth is fine and the second molar, a genuinely useful tooth, is being ruined by being pressed against something that cannot be cleaned. Restoring the back surface of a second molar with a wisdom tooth leaning on it is one of the most awkward jobs in dentistry.

A tooth that has come through with nothing biting against it, so it keeps erupting and ends up hitting the gum of the opposite jaw. A tooth you physically cannot reach with a brush. Recurring infection. And, occasionally, a cyst developing around a tooth that never came through, which shows on an x-ray long before it causes symptoms.

What we find on the x-ray and in the mouth, and what it usually means for that wisdom tooth
What we seeWhat it meansUsually
Fully erupted, upright, biting against an opposing tooth, cleanableA working molarLeave it, review at each visit
Fully buried in bone, no cyst, no symptoms, no contact with the tooth in frontNot causing anythingLeave it, keep an eye on it with x-rays
Partly through with a gum flap, infected more than onceIt will keep happeningRemove
Angled into the back of the second molarDecay risk to a tooth worth keepingRemove, often before damage starts
No opposing tooth, over-eruptingTraumatising the opposite gumRemove
Roots overlying the nerve canal on a flat x-rayNeeds measuring properly3D scan before any decision

Does age change the answer?

It changes the job, not the diagnosis. At nineteen the roots are often not fully formed, the bone is more elastic and healing is quick. At forty-five the roots are complete and sometimes curved around the nerve, the bone is denser, and recovery takes longer.

Which gives a genuinely useful rule. If a tooth is going to need removing eventually, earlier is easier. If it is not going to need removing, the fact that it would be easier now is not a reason to do it.

That distinction is the whole argument. Prophylactic removal of healthy teeth to save a hypothetical future problem is a trade I will discuss with you, but I will not present it as a foregone conclusion.

If yours have never been assessed, or you had an x-ray years ago and nobody explained it, book an examination and ask to see the picture. Ring 441 292-0107 and say it is about wisdom teeth so we allow the time.

Quiet interior photograph, soft grey daylight through a window on a rainy afternoon
Quiet interior photograph, soft grey daylight through a window on a rainy afternoon

What about the nerve?

The nerve that supplies feeling to your lower lip and chin runs through a canal in the lower jaw, sometimes very close to the roots of a lower wisdom tooth. On a flat x-ray the roots and the canal can appear to overlap when they are actually a few millimetres apart, and they can also genuinely be touching.

When the flat picture is ambiguous, the answer is a 3D scan, which shows the real relationship. If the roots are wrapped around the canal, we talk properly about the options, including a coronectomy, which means removing the crown of the tooth and deliberately leaving the root tips undisturbed where they are.

Numbness of the lip after lower wisdom tooth surgery is uncommon. It is not impossible, it is usually temporary, and on rare occasions it is not. Anybody who tells you the risk is zero is not telling you the truth, and this is exactly the kind of case where I will refer rather than press on if I think somebody else should do it. Complex surgical cases go to oral surgery, and knowing where my scope ends is part of the job.

What is recovery actually like?

For a straightforward upper tooth, often barely anything. A day of being careful. For a lower impacted tooth, expect three to five days of proper recovery, with swelling peaking on day two rather than day one, and a jaw that does not want to open fully for most of a week.

Ice on and off for the first day. Sleep propped up. Soft cool food. No rinsing at all on day one, and then warm salt water rinses gently from day two, several times a day. No straws, no smoking, and no spitting, because all three of those disturb the clot.

A dry socket is the complication people have heard of. It arrives around day three as a deep ache that spreads toward the ear, worse than the first two days rather than better, and it is far more common in smokers. It is unpleasant and it is quickly settled with a dressing, so ring 441 292-0107 rather than enduring it.

Book the surgery early in the week if you can. We are closed Saturday and Sunday, so a Monday or Tuesday appointment means there is a working day available if the clot gives you trouble. How each person recovers varies, and I will not give anybody a promise about it.

One I got wrong

I left a lower wisdom tooth in place for a patient in her late twenties. It was angled, but it was quiet, she had no symptoms and she cleaned well, and I took the conservative view I have been arguing for through this whole post.

Four years later the back surface of the second molar in front of it had decayed under the contact, in a place I could barely get an instrument to. We restored it, badly, because there was no good way to do it well, and then we took the wisdom tooth out anyway.

What changed for me is not the principle. It is the threshold. An angled tooth pressed against the second molar goes on a shorter review interval now and I take a picture of that contact more often, because the damage happens silently and by the time you can see it in the mouth it is already in the wrong place. Keeping your hygiene visits is how those get caught.

If someone has told you all four need to come out and you want a second look before you agree, bring your x-rays. Call 441 292-0107 or ask through the contact page.

Book a visit

Tell us what you need and when suits you. We will come back to you to confirm a time. If it is urgent, calling is faster.

  • New patients welcome, every age.
  • Free exams for children under three.
  • CG Insurance, Argus and BF&M claims filed for you.
  • Something hurting today? Call 441 292 0107.
441 292 0107

Request an appointment

We answer during practice hours, Monday to Friday.

Please do not send medical or treatment details through this form. We only use what you send here to answer your enquiry, and we never sell or share it.

Call Book a visit